|
Post by Dear-Dan on May 30, 2014 22:12:34 GMT
Dear all, Please see attached spreadsheet for the latest clan war analysis (thank you Sinfa). Anything that is not a win, is a loss. I am disappointed to see many people who didn't attack. I will be keeping an eye on those people. Guys, it's called "clan war" for a reason. We fight as a clan! Please drop your egos and attack someone slightly lower down if it means you will definitely 2/3 star them. Had we got 1 more star, we would have won. Sure, the higher up you go, the better the bonus. But what's the point of getting a high bonus, if we lose the war? You'll only be getting a quarter of that bonus! I sincerely hope we win our next war.
|
|
ghost
New Member
Posts: 7
|
Post by ghost on May 30, 2014 22:50:54 GMT
I have a suggestion, on top of your analysis you could do a leaderboard on our members after every war. showing the total star contributed per person (incentive to attack early).. so everyone can see how well they are doing compared to the other members.. I could help out with that if you want.. could be done in the same spreadsheet
|
|
|
Post by SinFa. on May 30, 2014 23:07:57 GMT
Clan War Report - baubau555
- Status: Draw - Score: 69 - 69
This Friday, we went against baubau555, where we drew against them at 69 - 69 points. baubau555 is a decent clan with a few skilled player (ie. Kevin - no. 1) who managed to 3* some of our clan's top players.
In this war, there are clear indications that our members are improving - more of us are now luring our clan castles first before launching a full-scale attack at their enemy base. However, we also made some mistakes, and it should be corrected in the next war.
1. We have 8 players that did not use any of their attacks, please refer to the list below for more information. If you do not spend your attacks 2 wars in a row, you will be kicked. Please attack at least once per war.
2. There are still several replays where our members failed to lure our clan castle troops first, leading to their troops quick demise. Remember, if you don't lure out the clan castle troops first, you are most likely going to have a BAD time.
3. There are members in the clan who are too cautious, where they don't send out their assault troops until all the enemy defences are destroyed. This is unnecessary. Note that base defences don't change targets unless their current target becomes out of range.
Let's all learn from our from this war and do better in the upcoming one!
|
|
|
Post by Dear-Dan on May 30, 2014 23:13:35 GMT
I have a suggestion, on top of your analysis you could do a leaderboard on our members after every war. showing the total star contributed per person (incentive to attack early).. so everyone can see how well they are doing compared to the other members.. I could help out with that if you want.. could be done in the same spreadsheet Yeah, would be great with your help KH. Sinfa did that spreadsheet all by himself. Any help would be appreciated. Please liaise with him accordingly.
|
|
ghost
New Member
Posts: 7
|
Post by ghost on May 31, 2014 0:07:29 GMT
So @sinfa @dan i added the cumulative tab at the bottom.. participation rate could edited with excel codes when people leave and enter the clan or have absence from war with valid reasons.. I would hope with this last tab - 1. those who have participation rates under 90% would be "in the kicklist", i.e. you are only allowed to miss 1 war every 10 wars.. I should also mention if you contributed 0 stars in the war it would be equivalent to not participating. (unless we could see you from replay you have tried your best and I would just +1 to the code) 2. you might see the column overall performance. To get a 100% you would need to have an average of 3 stars every war. As you can see our MvP senterou has 200% that's because he 6 star-ed the first war and have a performance of 2* average. If you did not participate in the war you would be given 0 stars which would pull down your overall performance. Remember a 100% overall performance doesn't mean you are a great player, it just means you are an average player. Anything below 100% (like ghost) is below average and need to step up your game ! CoC - Clan War Analysis 29-05-14 v2.xlsx (31.53 KB)
|
|
|
Post by oqipigiimua on Jun 10, 2019 3:30:56 GMT
|
|
|
Post by fooroabaew on Jun 10, 2019 5:11:03 GMT
|
|